Published February 7, 2010 by Chris Hogg
The healthcare industry is undergoing a dramatic and necessary transformation. Empowered patients are taking action and participating in their own healthcare, marking a significant change from the long-standing paternalistic relationship between physician and patient. Underlying this transformation is a new found access to health information via the internet and personal health data via consumer health devices and applications.
Much has been written about this long coming transformation, which has spawned the Health 2.0 movement, a successfulconference series of the same name started by Mathew Holt and Indu Subaiya, the peer reviewed Journal of Participatory Medicine and a series of grassroots unconferences championed by Mark Scrimshire.
To date, many have focused on the challenge of digitizing the vast amounts of health data in the current health system and on the one-way transfer of existing data from the system to the patient via EMRs and PHRs. Google and Microsoft have launched data warehouses for personal health information, and a few large institutions have embraced this one-way flow of information. The Mayo Clinic recently partnered with Microsoft HealthVault to provide patients access to their medical records, and Kaiser Permanente has been very successful with their “My Health Manager” offering.
Providing access to health information and health data is a logical first step. The foundation of the modern health industry is health data. Each time a prescription is dispensed (3.8 billion times in 2007), a medical claim is submitted, or a lab is ordered, a piece of personal health data is generated. Evidence-based treatment guidelines often focus on specific health data values, such as BP, LDL or HbA1c, for treatment recommendations. And a modern medical record is simply an aggregation of health data generated at the point of care, including patient reported symptoms, diagnoses, treatments, test results, physician commentary and observations. However, medical records are punctuated data streams with large gaps in data from time periods in between physician visits. It is the doctor’s difficult job to fill in these gaps with imperfect information recounted by the patient to complete the picture and treat the patient effectively.
Focusing only on the EMR, or the one-way transmission of personal health data from the system to the patient, misses half of the health data equation. With increasing frequency, patients are beginning to generate and report their own personal health data. Sites such as CureTogether and PatientsLikeMe are collecting patient reported data, analyzing the data and generating valuable services for their members. And recently, we have seen a rapid rise in ‘health trackers’ to record health and wellness information (MedHelp, TheCarrot, DailyMile, hLog, Polka,Ringful). Data is also being collected and uploaded in the home by personal health devices such as BP monitors with SD cards, WiFi weight scales, USB glucose metersand activity monitors, some now sold at Best Buy. To date, these patient generated data streams have existed in silos, both disconnected from traditional data streams generated within the current health system and from data generated on other sites.
In the future, each individual’s traditional health data stream (EMR) and user-generated data streams will merge into one personal health data stream, or healthstream, and this healthstream will be owned solely by the patient. Diagnoses, treatment decisions and lab results will be overlaid on top of more frequently added data from the patient including symptoms, adherence to medication, daily weight, diet, mood, activity levels, sleep patterns, etc. This complete longitudinal data stream will be valuable to both the physician and patient and become a part of everyday medical practice. Physicians will prescribe trackers, apps and home health devices, along with their standard Rx, and will receive a report at the patient’s next visit. Rather than relying on recollections, physicians will have more complete pictures of their patients, and patients will begin to feel like partners in their own care.
This longitudinal healthstream will become a valuable asset for the patient, and will increase in value with each added data point. Patients will have the right to grant permission to use all or part of their healthstream for medical care, for research and discovery, or even for profit. I will explore the topics of permission and use of the healthstream in future posts.
For another view of the future of the healthstream, see Dr. Vijay Goel’s post“HealthStreaming: What data would you need in your stream to make your health decisions?”